Jarod Apperson addresses class size issue – concludes that YES they matter

Jarod Apperson is a CPA, forensic accountant and currently working on a Ph.D. in economics, consistently writes well documented pieces on a variety of education issues and publishes them at his blog – Grading Atlanta.

In advance of the Atlanta Public School Board of Education reconsidering the maximum class size waiver in a special meeting (see more here and here), Apperson sent the following email to Superintendent Meria Carstarphen and  copied all Board of Education members. As usual, Jarod is thorough and presents his fact based conclusions in a clear and well documented fashion.

As noted in a prior post, the Board of Education reversed its prior decision and approved the +5 class waiver (see here).

Apperson’s assessment was published in full at the AJC’s Get Schooled blog. Here are some key excerpts:

From my understanding of the class-size research and knowledge of the Atlanta schools, I have become persuaded that a substantial reduction in class size would be the easiest action you could take to improve student learning.

Below, I present a series of relevant questions and attempt to provide informative answers.

Are smaller class sizes an effective means to raise student achievement? – Yes…Credible research design is essential to developing good causal estimates, and both randomized experiments and quasi-experimental research indicates that class size reductions positively impact student achievement.

Evidence from the Tennessee STAR experiment shows that students assigned to classes with a maximum of 17 students scored 0.15 to 0.20 standard deviations above students assigned to classes with a maximum of 25 students.  Thus, the experiment’s results suggest by reducing its maximum class size by 8 students, APS could close between 60% and 80% of its achievement gap with the state…Importantly, both studies indicate that the positive effects are even larger for disadvantaged students, a significant fact in a district were approximately 80% of students qualify for free and reduced lunch….

Unfortunately, the debate on class size was muddied by a number of ill-designed studies in the 1980’s and 1990’s that purported to show no effect, but in fact did not employ empirical designs that would allow the researchers to isolate the effect of class size on student achievement. 

So, yes, reducing class size is an effective means to raise student achievement. 

Are smaller class sizes easier to implement than other initiatives?  Yes. For reasons that are not always clear to me, class-size discussions in the district often meander into a territory where class size is pitted against effective teachers…First, it is a false choice.  Reductions in class size need not come at the expense hiring effective teachers.  Second, reducing class size is easy while placing an effective teacher in every classroom is easier said than done…

APS can and should raise the bar for teacher selection, but results will undoubtedly be incremental.  Class size reductions are an effective policy that can be implemented immediately, and there is no credible reason they should come at the expense of prioritizing effective teaching hires.

[Conclusion] If APS allocates additional teachers to all its schools, including Title 1 schools, that frees up supplemental resources.  It returns those resources for use in targeted interventions aimed at the students most in need.

Please read the whole thing here.

[Follow me on Twitter @Financial_Decon & Facebook]

4 Responses to Jarod Apperson addresses class size issue – concludes that YES they matter

  1. Beverly Fraud says:

    Yes class size does matter. And yes it does matter that one is honest and ethical in matters dealing with students. And this superintendent, and this board that voted with her, have proven to be neither.

    There is no need to sugar coat this; it is what it is; a board that has proven itself to be largely dishonest and unethical supporting a superintendent that has proven to be the same, (but doesn’t get called to account-yet-because she looks good in comparison to the progenitor of academic genocide that proceeded her.)

    Don’t say you weren’t told, BEFORE she was hired, because indeed people were saying it.

  2. Beverly Fraud says:

    Jarod Apperson’s analysis makes one thing clear: this is not a matter of people “disagreeing on policy.”

    This is a matter of a school board and superintendent behaving in a MOST unethical manner, behind closed doors not unlike the old Soviet politburo.

    In short, it’s Beverly Hall 2.0 without the organized criminal enterprise…at least for now…

  3. Beverly Fraud says:

    Robert this is (allegedly, according to a Get Schooled poster) part of the email response Westmoreland gave to an inquiry about the vote.

    “Will try and respond to your requests in reverse order. First, this isn’t an Emergency Legislative Meeting. I believe we’ve only had one, on March 26, when we selected Meria. This is a called legislative meeting– something that can happen at the discretion of the chair or when three Board members ask the chair for a meeting.

    Perhaps he would respond to the following from you: If it WASN’T an “emergency” why not give the public time to respond and show up?

    Note – certain parts of this post have been removed due to the inappropriate nature of the comments. Bob

    • Ms. Fraud – at some point, enough is enough and stepping over the line calling a Board members ethics and integrity into question over a normal Board conduct and procedures is a step too far.

      There are specific steps that the Board must follow by law in calling a meeting. Those steps were followed and the meeting was legally held. The fact that you do not like the process or wanted a different outcome does not change that fact.

      As for calling into question a Board member’s ethics and integrity for performing their job in a legal and transparent way is beyond the pale. As a result, I have edited your comments to remove the offending remarks. In the future, I would ask that – while you are free to voice your opinions – that you refrain from any further unwarranted personal attacks.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: